I've used all variants of the deck posted and the Force of Will/Chancellor of the Annex list is just inconsistent in mulligans and vs hate, I'm sure it has a better game 1 vs B/r Reanimator but I know it has a worse match up because Faerie Macabre or whatever else makes no sense over Leyline of the Void in a deck that doesn't draw cards. Vs D&T, I bring in shoal (all their real threats cost two) and pharaos but no contagion, which are lackluster vs Thalia & mom, and remove some 3 probes, 1 amalgam, 1 CotA and 1 phantasmagorian. Drop MB trap, which does next to nothing vs rea and is less good than FoW vs storm. Listwise, I would advise 4 FoW and 4 CotA MD and a mix of noxious, faeries and surgical SB plus shoals & pharaos. I personally feel that the deck is "too consistent", and that we should lower its consistency in order to be more reactive/disruptive, as ignoring what our opponent is doing is a problem vs faster decks. Consider that it could be because you tried to have a very resilient deck. You speak about loading up on dudes, which are useless against combo, and then complain than you can't beat the fastest combo deck. But if you cannot beat this deck, you should consider that either your list or your plays are wrong (to beat this deck). Maybe you run really hot vs the deck, but I haven't been able to beat it in a 3 round match without Leyline - and I fail to see how Surgical Extraction is any better vs the deck when it runs afoul of disruption and doesnt win the game outright, why dedicate SB space to a lower impact card?I'm not making any ad hominem. I honestly don't understand why you continue to devolve the argument into ad hominems, I've played the deck for a long time and played the deck vs B/r Reanimator recently, and considering B/r Reanimator is a DTB and has a generally positive win rate vs aggro-control I don't see how you can claim that Manaless Dredge has a positive win rate vs it with even less disruption.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |